Group: rec.arts.movies.past-films
From: "Wull"
Date: Monday, October 29, 2007 5:38 PM
Subject: Re: Tarantino: Idea Thief

Scorsese is not French, they are both Italian. Since you are calling
Tarentino spoiled food, you must be a food expert?
While French is unquestionably good, some people prefer Italian food.

I have seen only a few Tarentino movies and I think most of them were quite
a success.
I missed earlier posts on this subject so I assume that you are comparing
their directorship ability? One has considerably more experience but the
other shows promise. Both being Italian is a good point in their favor.

What was the stolen idea?

Wull

"Magnus, Robot Fighter" wrote in message
news:aoqci395pbpu43h4sniniseb4ilv3qama2@ ...
> On Sun, 28 Oct 2007 16:57:51 -0700, Michael O'Connor
> wrote:
>
>>
>>> Comparing Tatantino to Scorsese is like comparing spoiled food to fine
>>> french cuisine. :) Tarantino is a one-note Johnny.
>>
>>Yes, but I was making a point that you can be best known as a director
>>who makes crime and gangster films, but still manage to flesh out your
>>resume with an eclectic mix of movies. Tarantino would rather re-
>>create 70's B cinema than take genuine risks.
>>
>
> I think the point was there's only one Scorcese...you really can't
> compare someone like Tarantino to him.